Back to top

Image: Bigstock

Real World vs. Theoretical Investing: Part 2

Read MoreHide Full Article

Below is part 2 of my series “Real-World Investing vs. Theoretical Investing.” If you missed part 1, you can find it here.

Real World Investors Look for Subtle Clues

Below are two of my most relied-upon clues:

The Reaction to the News Supersedes the News Itself: In late 2023, the SEC sued Coinbase ((COIN - Free Report) ). Rather than succumbing to poor news, the stock rallied back to where it was pre-lawsuit announcement within days. Investors should focus on the reaction to news instead of the news itself.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Relative Strength: Relative strength is a simple but effective measure of a stock’s potential.  Simply put, investors should look for stocks showing unusual divergence versus the general market (this works especially well in down markets because RS names are easier to identify). For example, when equities hit multi-year lows in 2022, Super Micro Computer ((SMCI - Free Report) ) knocked on the door of 52-week highs. Ask yourself: “If the stock is hitting new highs in a brutal bear market, what will happen when the market pressure is alleviated?” SMCI went on to multi-bag over the next few months and hasn’t turned back since.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Successful Trading is About Having an Edge Over a Series of Trades

Peter Brandt’s motto is:“Strong opinions, weakly held.”

New investors are typically unconcerned with the investing process and want to focus on finding a “hot” stock pick. Successful trading is not about any given trade but rather about having an edge over a series of trades (like a casino).

In an interview a few years ago, billionaire investor Paul Tudor Jones explained his risk/reward framework:

“Five to one means I’m risking one dollar to make five. What five to one does is allow you to have a hit rate of 20%. I can actually be a complete imbecile. I can be wrong 80% of the time, and I’m still not going to lose.”

Lesson: Investors can be wrong more than right and still make a fortune on Wall Street. Shoot for outsized winners and small losers, and the math will work over time. Pay attention to the simple math behind successful trading!

Interpret vs. Predict

Last year, nearly every Wall Street analyst was wrong in their predictions. Real-world investors understand the importance of flexibility and focus on interpreting the current market action rather than making grandiose and bold predictions about the future.

Market Direction is Paramount

Most investors feel genius in a bull market and dumb in a bear market. The cold, hard truth is that about 75% of stocks follow the market direction. What separates profitable investors from unprofitable investors is their ability to recognize and take advantage of trend change. The 200-day moving average is a simple but effective tool for monitoring the intermediate to long-term market trend.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: TradingView

Know Your Timeframe

Amateur investors often do not know their time frames. Without a framework, it’s impossible to understand the trend of the stock you are trading. Worse, many investors argue on social media about a specific stock. The truth is that one investor can be long while another investor is short, and they can both be correct (due to differing time frames)! Knowing and sticking to your time frame is critical to success!

Being Right vs Making Money

Years ago, two billionaire adversaries got into a public dispute on CNBC and took opposite sides of a trade. Bill Ackman shorted Herbalife ((HLF - Free Report) ), citing thatit was a pyramid scheme and he would hold his short “until the end of the Earth” if necessary. Meanwhile, Carl Icahn bought tons of HLF shares and forced a short squeeze. Ackman ultimately threw in the towel and lost nearly $1 billion on the HLF trade after Icahn forced a classic short squeeze.

Recently, Ackman took to X (formerly Twitter) to point out that his fundamental thesis about HLF after stock cratered recently was correct. Nonetheless, discussing whether you’re right on a trade you lost money on is futile. Successful trades have three characteristics:

1.       Correct on direction.

2.       Correct on timing.

3.       Profitable

Ackman was correct on the fundamental thesis, yet he lost money. Correct trades are trades that are profitable, full stop. Never let your ego tell you otherwise.

The Best Investors are Even Keel

In studying my and other’s investing histories, the biggest portfolio drawdowns occur after large upside moves in equity curves. The best investors never get overly-emotional about wins or losses. Furthermore, if you find yourself celebrating like you just won the Superbowl, you’re probably trading a position size that is far too large.  

Bottom Line: Simplicity is the Ultimate Sophistication (Focus on the Intangibles)

Instead of overcomplicating investing, savvy and profitable investors keep things as simple as possible. They understand liquidity (never fight the Fed), the general market trend (75% of stocks follow it), and are hyper-focused on risk and sound money management above all else. Remember, profitability is more important than academic history, prestigious awards, or sounding intelligent.


See More Zacks Research for These Tickers


Normally $25 each - click below to receive one report FREE:


Super Micro Computer, Inc. (SMCI) - free report >>

Herbalife Ltd (HLF) - free report >>

Coinbase Global, Inc. (COIN) - free report >>

Published in