Member Sign In

Insurance is something people buy because they need it, not because they want it. The agent who sells and manages your policy plays a crucial role in ensuring it fits your needs and budget. You may need to change your agent at some point, even if you want to carry on with the same insurance company. Your agent may retire, or perhaps you may prefer someone more attentive. But unless there is a change to your policy, simply switching agents with the same insurance provider will not get you a better price or lower your premiums.

Agents Matter, But Not for Pricing

Agents act as intermediaries between you and your insurance provider. Some work independently and can offer products from multiple insurers, while others are “captive” agents who represent only one company. Either way, their job is to help you find policies that work for you.

However, what they cannot do is negotiate your premium. Rates are set by the insurer, not the agent. Two different agents at the same company quoting the same product will always land on the same price. That is because insurance pricing is based on underwriting classes — groups of similar risks — rather than personal negotiation. Therefore, switching agents alone will not alter your bill.

When Can a New Agent be Valuable?

While a new agent cannot change the pricing formula, they may help you find better value. A skilled agent can recommend a different policy structure by removing unnecessary add-ons or modifying coverage amounts, lowering your premium without changing providers.

In some cases, insurers roll out the latest products or rate structures that are not automatically applied to existing customers. A sharp agent may spot these and guide you through applying for a different plan with the same company, leading to savings. The key here is that savings do not come from switching agents but from actively restructuring your insurance strategy.

Real Costs Behind Your Premium

Your insurance costs are influenced by factors such as your age, location, driving record (for auto insurance), health status (for life or health insurance) and claim history. Insurance companies are also affected by broader trends like inflation, rising repair costs and climate-related disasters, which means that even if you switch providers or agents, some price hikes are simply unavoidable.

Because of these industry-wide factors, switching to a new insurer in search of better rates may not deliver the savings you hope for. Often, new policies come with exclusions or waiting periods, especially with life insurance, which reset when you switch, creating a setback in terms of long-term protection.

Is it Ever a Good Idea to Switch Companies?

There are certainly times when changing insurance companies makes sense. If you are facing large, unexplained rate hikes or poor customer service, it may be time to shop around. However, hopping between insurers often can hurt you in the long run. Some companies see frequent switchers as higher-risk customers and may charge more or offer fewer benefits.

Loyalty can pay off. Many insurers offer perks like bundling discounts, accident forgiveness, or renewal bonuses. You may also find that claims are processed more smoothly when you have been with a company for a while and have a consistent history. Instead of constantly jumping ship, it is more effective to review your current policy, inquire about available discounts or explore usage-based options that align with your behavior.

Bottom Line

Changing your insurance agent within the same company will not magically lower your premiums. Insurance pricing is influenced by risk categories, not the individual agent. That said, a proactive and knowledgeable agent can help you reassess your coverage and identify more effective ways to save, especially if your needs have changed since you purchased the policy.

If your current agent is not meeting your expectations, switching can still be worthwhile for better service and more personalized advice. But when it comes to dollars and cents, do not expect that agent to make a financial difference unless you also take the time to reevaluate your coverage.