We use cookies to understand how you use our site and to improve your experience.
This includes personalizing content and advertising.
By pressing "Accept All" or closing out of this banner, you consent to the use of all cookies and similar technologies and the sharing of information they collect with third parties.
You can reject marketing cookies by pressing "Deny Optional," but we still use essential, performance, and functional cookies.
In addition, whether you "Accept All," Deny Optional," click the X or otherwise continue to use the site, you accept our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service, revised from time to time.
You are being directed to ZacksTrade, a division of LBMZ Securities and licensed broker-dealer. ZacksTrade and Zacks.com are separate companies. The web link between the two companies is not a solicitation or offer to invest in a particular security or type of security. ZacksTrade does not endorse or adopt any particular investment strategy, any analyst opinion/rating/report or any approach to evaluating individual securities.
If you wish to go to ZacksTrade, click OK. If you do not, click Cancel.
Home Depot's Best Comp of the Year Arrives With a Thinner Margin
Home Depot reported fiscal third-quarter results before the open this morning, and the market's verdict was immediate and mildly negative: shares traded down about 1% in the early going despite a clear revenue beat. That reaction is worth explaining, because the headline numbers do not obviously justify it.
Sales rose 4.9% to $43.4 billion, ahead of consensus near $42.7 billion. Comparable sales advanced 2.2%, with U.S. comps also up 2.2%, against Street expectations closer to 1.5%. Adjusted earnings came in at $3.86 per share, up 3.2% from $3.74, which merely matched the Zacks Consensus Estimate. Incoming CEO Richard McPhail said results "exceeded our expectations," and on the top line they plainly did.
The Margin Is Where It Gets Uncomfortable
Underneath the beat, profitability moved the wrong way. Gross profit grew 2.9% against 4.9% sales growth, putting gross margin near 32.8% versus roughly 33.4% a year ago. Operating margin fell to 12.6% from 12.9%, and to 13.0% from 13.3% on an adjusted basis. Net earnings rose just 3.1% on a 4.9% sales increase.
That is the signature of a company buying growth rather than earning it. Sales grew 4.9% while comps grew 2.2%, which means roughly two and a half points of the top line came from SRS and the other acquired businesses. SRS now spans more than 1,320 locations, and it is distribution — structurally lower-margin than the retail box. Home Depot bought its way into professional supply, the strategy is working on the revenue line, and the bill arrives as margin dilution.
Guidance Is Where the Story Actually Changed
The full-year update is the most informative part of this release, and it cuts both ways. Management lifted total sales growth to approximately 4.5%, the very top of the prior 2.5% to 4.5% range, and set comparable sales at about 1.4% within a prior band of flat to 2%. Good news.
Then look at the profit lines. Gross margin guidance eased to about 33.0% from 33.1%. GAAP operating margin was set at about 12.4% — the bottom of the prior 12.4% to 12.6% range — and adjusted operating margin at about 12.8%, again the bottom of its range. The effective tax rate moved up to roughly 24.6% from 24.3%. Adjusted diluted EPS growth of about 2.0% from $14.69 works out to roughly $14.98, essentially the midpoint of the prior flat-to-4% band.
Sales to the high end, margins to the low end. That is the entire premarket reaction in one sentence.
One more item the guidance implies that nobody will headline. Nine-month comps are running at 1.5% and the full year is now pegged at about 1.4%, which backs into fourth-quarter comps somewhere around 1% — a deceleration from the 2.2% just delivered. Management is not forecasting that this quarter's momentum continues through the holidays.
A Comp That Should Not Exist
Here is what genuinely impresses me, and it deserves more attention than the margin miss. Home Depot posted its strongest comparable sales of the year during a quarter in which existing home sales fell to 3.75 million on a seasonally adjusted annual basis — down 8.8% year over year and the slowest pace since 2010 — with the 30-year mortgage rate averaging 7.33% in October and the highest readings since 2000.
The conventional model says home improvement spending follows housing turnover, because people renovate when they move. That relationship has broken, at least temporarily. Rate lock-in is keeping owners in place, and owners who cannot move eventually improve what they have. Record home equity funds the work. The aging of the U.S. housing stock makes it necessary.
For Home Depot specifically, this is the argument that the floor under demand is sturdier than the housing data implies. It is also the argument that the ceiling stays low until rates come down and the big-ticket discretionary projects return.
Traffic Is Still Negative
The detail I would not let pass: comparable customer transactions declined 0.5%, while comparable average ticket rose 3.0% to $93.09. Every bit of the comp came from people spending more per visit, not from more visits. It is improving — transactions were down 1.0% in the second quarter — but it is still negative.
This is the defining pattern across retail right now, and Home Depot (HD - Free Report) is not an outlier. Best Buy has reported mid-teens increases in computing average selling prices against high-single-digit declines in units. Costco's headline comps have been flattered by fuel inflation. Across the sector, dollar growth is increasingly a price story rather than a volume story. That works until the pricing comparison laps itself, and then the underlying unit trend is what remains.
What It Means for the Group
Lowe's (LOW - Free Report) reports tomorrow morning, and the setup rhymes: the Zacks Consensus Estimate calls for $2.86 per share, a 6.5% decline, on revenue of $22.38 billion, up 7.5%.
Revenue growing on acquisitions while earnings shrink is becoming the home improvement sector's signature, and Lowe's will likely confirm it. Home Depot trades at roughly 23 times forward earnings against about 18 for Lowe's and 19 for the industry, a premium that now has to be defended with margin rather than growth.
Bottom Line
This was a good operating quarter inside a difficult housing market, and the demand resilience is real.
But Home Depot is converting less of each sales dollar into profit, the mix shift toward professional distribution is structural rather than temporary, and management's own guidance points to a slower fourth quarter. The shares have gained about 2% year to date against 8.3% for the S&P 500, and today's reaction suggests investors want evidence of margin stabilization before paying up again.
Image: Bigstock
Home Depot's Best Comp of the Year Arrives With a Thinner Margin
Home Depot reported fiscal third-quarter results before the open this morning, and the market's verdict was immediate and mildly negative: shares traded down about 1% in the early going despite a clear revenue beat. That reaction is worth explaining, because the headline numbers do not obviously justify it.
Sales rose 4.9% to $43.4 billion, ahead of consensus near $42.7 billion. Comparable sales advanced 2.2%, with U.S. comps also up 2.2%, against Street expectations closer to 1.5%. Adjusted earnings came in at $3.86 per share, up 3.2% from $3.74, which merely matched the Zacks Consensus Estimate. Incoming CEO Richard McPhail said results "exceeded our expectations," and on the top line they plainly did.
The Margin Is Where It Gets Uncomfortable
Underneath the beat, profitability moved the wrong way. Gross profit grew 2.9% against 4.9% sales growth, putting gross margin near 32.8% versus roughly 33.4% a year ago. Operating margin fell to 12.6% from 12.9%, and to 13.0% from 13.3% on an adjusted basis. Net earnings rose just 3.1% on a 4.9% sales increase.
That is the signature of a company buying growth rather than earning it. Sales grew 4.9% while comps grew 2.2%, which means roughly two and a half points of the top line came from SRS and the other acquired businesses. SRS now spans more than 1,320 locations, and it is distribution — structurally lower-margin than the retail box. Home Depot bought its way into professional supply, the strategy is working on the revenue line, and the bill arrives as margin dilution.
Guidance Is Where the Story Actually Changed
The full-year update is the most informative part of this release, and it cuts both ways. Management lifted total sales growth to approximately 4.5%, the very top of the prior 2.5% to 4.5% range, and set comparable sales at about 1.4% within a prior band of flat to 2%. Good news.
Then look at the profit lines. Gross margin guidance eased to about 33.0% from 33.1%. GAAP operating margin was set at about 12.4% — the bottom of the prior 12.4% to 12.6% range — and adjusted operating margin at about 12.8%, again the bottom of its range. The effective tax rate moved up to roughly 24.6% from 24.3%. Adjusted diluted EPS growth of about 2.0% from $14.69 works out to roughly $14.98, essentially the midpoint of the prior flat-to-4% band.
Sales to the high end, margins to the low end. That is the entire premarket reaction in one sentence.
One more item the guidance implies that nobody will headline. Nine-month comps are running at 1.5% and the full year is now pegged at about 1.4%, which backs into fourth-quarter comps somewhere around 1% — a deceleration from the 2.2% just delivered. Management is not forecasting that this quarter's momentum continues through the holidays.
A Comp That Should Not Exist
Here is what genuinely impresses me, and it deserves more attention than the margin miss. Home Depot posted its strongest comparable sales of the year during a quarter in which existing home sales fell to 3.75 million on a seasonally adjusted annual basis — down 8.8% year over year and the slowest pace since 2010 — with the 30-year mortgage rate averaging 7.33% in October and the highest readings since 2000.
The conventional model says home improvement spending follows housing turnover, because people renovate when they move. That relationship has broken, at least temporarily. Rate lock-in is keeping owners in place, and owners who cannot move eventually improve what they have. Record home equity funds the work. The aging of the U.S. housing stock makes it necessary.
For Home Depot specifically, this is the argument that the floor under demand is sturdier than the housing data implies. It is also the argument that the ceiling stays low until rates come down and the big-ticket discretionary projects return.
Traffic Is Still Negative
The detail I would not let pass: comparable customer transactions declined 0.5%, while comparable average ticket rose 3.0% to $93.09. Every bit of the comp came from people spending more per visit, not from more visits. It is improving — transactions were down 1.0% in the second quarter — but it is still negative.
This is the defining pattern across retail right now, and Home Depot (HD - Free Report) is not an outlier. Best Buy has reported mid-teens increases in computing average selling prices against high-single-digit declines in units. Costco's headline comps have been flattered by fuel inflation. Across the sector, dollar growth is increasingly a price story rather than a volume story. That works until the pricing comparison laps itself, and then the underlying unit trend is what remains.
What It Means for the Group
Lowe's (LOW - Free Report) reports tomorrow morning, and the setup rhymes: the Zacks Consensus Estimate calls for $2.86 per share, a 6.5% decline, on revenue of $22.38 billion, up 7.5%.
Revenue growing on acquisitions while earnings shrink is becoming the home improvement sector's signature, and Lowe's will likely confirm it. Home Depot trades at roughly 23 times forward earnings against about 18 for Lowe's and 19 for the industry, a premium that now has to be defended with margin rather than growth.
Bottom Line
This was a good operating quarter inside a difficult housing market, and the demand resilience is real.
But Home Depot is converting less of each sales dollar into profit, the mix shift toward professional distribution is structural rather than temporary, and management's own guidance points to a slower fourth quarter. The shares have gained about 2% year to date against 8.3% for the S&P 500, and today's reaction suggests investors want evidence of margin stabilization before paying up again.