Real estate companies continue to operate in an environment influenced by interest rates, construction activity and property development trends. Against this backdrop, AMREP Corporation (AXR Quick QuoteAXR - Free Report) and FRP Holdings, Inc. (FRPH Quick QuoteFRPH - Free Report) are two real estate companies with meaningful land and development exposure but different operating strategies. AXR primarily focuses on land development and homebuilding in New Mexico, while FRPH operates a more diversified real estate business spanning property development, leasing, multifamily assets and mining royalty lands.

While both companies participate in real estate development, their operating models differ meaningfully. AMREP has a more concentrated residential development profile, whereas FRP Holdings has a broader mix of real estate and income-producing assets. These differences in business mix and operating exposure create distinct investment profiles, raising the question: which company is better positioned to create long-term shareholder value? Let’s take a closer look.

Stock Performance & Valuation: AXR vs. FRPH

AXR (down 15.7%) has outperformed FRPH (down 18%) over the past three months. In the past year, AMREP has declined 8.5% compared with FRP Holdings’ decline of 15.5%.

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Meanwhile, AXR is trading at a trailing 12-month enterprise value-to-sales (EV/S) ratio of 1.55X, above its median of 1.46X over the past five years. FRPH’s trailing 12-month EV/S multiple sits at 11.49X, above its last five-year median of 9.97X. While AXR appears cheap when compared with the Zacks Finance sector’s average of 1.84X, FRPH seems to be expensive.

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Factors Driving AMREP Stock

AMREP is placing greater emphasis on its homebuilding operations, which gives the company a more direct way to monetize its land position and participate in residential demand. The company has increased the number of homes in production, supporting a broader pipeline of future closings. This strategy also allows AXR to capture more value from developed lots rather than relying solely on third-party land sales.

AMREP’s sizable land holdings in New Mexico remain a core strategic asset. The portfolio can be used for residential development, commercial and industrial projects or selective land sales depending on market conditions. This flexibility gives management multiple avenues to unlock value over time and adjust development activity as demand changes, supporting the long-term potential of the real estate business.

AMREP’s balance sheet remains a key strength, with substantial liquidity and only minimal debt. This financial position gives the company greater flexibility to fund land development, home construction and potential property acquisitions without relying heavily on external financing. It also provides a cushion during periods of softer housing demand or delayed project activity.

Factors Aiding FRP Holdings Stock

FRP Holdings is increasingly directing growth capital toward industrial real estate, which management views as its most attractive long-term opportunity. The Altman Logistics acquisition broadened the company’s development capabilities and added scale to the platform, while multiple warehouse projects are moving through construction and completion. Improving tenant inquiries and leasing discussions also point to better utilization potential as these assets are delivered and stabilized.

FRP Holdings’ Mining Royalty Lands segment remains a steady contributor, benefiting from favorable trends in both royalty volumes and pricing. The business is relatively capital-light and generates recurring cash flow, which helps diversify FRPH’s operating base beyond traditional leasing and development activities. This recurring contribution can provide support even when other real estate segments face occupancy or lease-up pressure.

FRP Holdings’ financial position remains a notable strength, supported by substantial liquidity and conservative leverage. This balance-sheet cushion gives the company greater resilience during periods of uneven leasing or development activity and reduces dependence on external capital. It also provides management with flexibility to remain selective on investments and preserve capital-allocation discipline through changing real estate conditions.

Choose AXR Over FRPH Now

AMREP and FRP Holdings both offer exposure to real estate development, but their investment cases rest on different strengths. AXR combines a sizable land portfolio with an expanding homebuilding operation, giving it multiple avenues to create value from its assets. Its strong liquidity position also provides flexibility to support development activity and navigate periods of uneven housing demand.

FRP Holdings offers a broader real estate platform spanning industrial, multifamily, development and mining royalty assets. Its industrial expansion strategy and improving leasing activity could strengthen future income generation, while the mining royalty business adds a recurring, capital-light cash flow stream. FRPH also benefits from a solid balance sheet that supports continued investment across its development pipeline.

From a valuation standpoint, however, AMREP appears more attractive. Its current valuation remains closer to its historical range and below the broader sector average, suggesting investors are paying a comparatively modest price for its land and homebuilding exposure. FRP Holdings trades at a premium to both its own historical valuation and the sector, implying that the market is already assigning considerable value to its diversified portfolio and future development potential. This leaves less room for execution delays or weaker-than-expected leasing progress.

Considering fundamentals alongside valuation, AXR appears to be the better buy at present. FRPH has credible long-term growth opportunities, but AMREP’s land base, homebuilding expansion, financial flexibility and more favorable valuation create a more balanced risk-reward profile for investors.