We use cookies to understand how you use our site and to improve your experience.
This includes personalizing content and advertising.
By pressing "Accept All" or closing out of this banner, you consent to the use of all cookies and similar technologies and the sharing of information they collect with third parties.
You can reject marketing cookies by pressing "Deny Optional," but we still use essential, performance, and functional cookies.
In addition, whether you "Accept All," Deny Optional," click the X or otherwise continue to use the site, you accept our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service, revised from time to time.
You are being directed to ZacksTrade, a division of LBMZ Securities and licensed broker-dealer. ZacksTrade and Zacks.com are separate companies. The web link between the two companies is not a solicitation or offer to invest in a particular security or type of security. ZacksTrade does not endorse or adopt any particular investment strategy, any analyst opinion/rating/report or any approach to evaluating individual securities.
If you wish to go to ZacksTrade, click OK. If you do not, click Cancel.
DK vs. DINO: Which Refining Stock Has the Edge After Q3 Earnings?
Read MoreHide Full Article
Key Takeaways
Delek and HF Sinclair delivered strong Q3 results, fueled by robust refining margins and operational gains.
Delek's shares gained 131% compared with HF Sinclair's 121.8%, while its forward P/E is 9.5% lower.
Delek's optimization gains and cheaper valuation give it an edge, while HF Sinclair offers financial strength.
U.S. refiners Delek US Holdings (DK - Free Report) and HF Sinclair Corporation (DINO - Free Report) delivered impressive third-quarter 2026 results, supported by robust refining margins, favorable market conditions and improved operational performance. Both companies are benefiting from strong industry fundamentals while pursuing initiatives to enhance profitability, strengthen their balance sheets and reward shareholders.
While Delek is gaining momentum from the Enterprise Optimization Plan (“EOP”), HF Sinclair benefits from its diversified operations and considerable financial flexibility. With both stocks delivering exceptional gains this year, let's examine their fundamentals, earnings estimates, price performance and valuations to determine which offers a more compelling investment opportunity.
The Case for Delek US Holdings
Delek reported third-quarter revenues of $4.39 billion, increasing approximately 52% year over year. Adjusted EBITDA surged to $1.28 billion from $766.7 million in the prior-year quarter. Excluding regulatory-related adjustments associated with renewable volume obligations and small refinery exemptions, adjusted EBITDA reached an impressive $1.04 billion.
The company's EOP continues to deliver meaningful improvements. Management raised its annual run-rate free cash flow improvement target to at least $250 million from $220 million. The program contributed approximately $60 million during the quarter, highlighting progress in operational efficiency and refining margin capture.
Delek is also targeting an additional $1-per-barrel net margin improvement at its El Dorado refinery through optimized feedstock selection, product placement and higher-value yields.
Its financial position is strengthening. The company ended September with approximately $1.34 billion in consolidated cash and a standalone net cash position of nearly $22 million, excluding Delek Logistics. Management expects to repay approximately $850 million in term debt during the fourth quarter, supporting lower financing costs.
Additionally, Delek increased the quarterly dividend approximately 18% to 30 cents per share and plans roughly $100 million in fourth-quarter share repurchases, underscoring its commitment to shareholder returns.
The Case for HF Sinclair
HF Sinclair also delivered outstanding third-quarter results, with revenues increasing approximately 50% year over year to $10.86 billion. Adjusted EBITDA surged to $2.98 billion from $870 million a year earlier, while adjusted earnings jumped to $11.75 per share from $2.44.
Its refining segment generated adjusted EBITDA of $2.58 billion, compared with $661 million in the prior-year quarter. Adjusted refinery gross margin improved significantly to $54.22 per produced barrel sold from $19.16, benefiting from strong crack spreads and favorable market dynamics.
HF Sinclair's diversified portfolio provides additional growth opportunities. Its lubricants and specialties segment recorded adjusted EBITDA of $174 million, compared with $78 million a year earlier. Renewable fuels and midstream operations further complement its refining business. The company also maintains a robust financial position, ending September with approximately $3.33 billion in cash against $2.77 billion in debt, translating into net cash of around $559 million. Shareholder returns remain impressive. HF Sinclair returned $572 million to its shareholders through dividends and share repurchases during the quarter and declared a quarterly dividend of 52.5 cents per share.
How Do the Earnings Estimates Compare?
Both refining companies have witnessed substantial upward earnings estimate revisions, highlighting growing analyst confidence in their profitability prospects.
The Zacks Consensus Estimate for Earnings’ Trend
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
Over the past 60 days, the Zacks Consensus Estimate for Delek's 2026 earnings increased 36.98%, from $14.71 to $20.15 per share. HF Sinclair's corresponding earnings estimate climbed 38.12%, from $16.16 to $22.32 per share.
For 2027, Delek's earnings estimate surged 59.60%, while HF Sinclair's increased 57.49%. These encouraging revisions demonstrate strengthening expectations for both companies.
Although HF Sinclair has higher projected earnings per share, Delek's slightly stronger 2027 estimate revision momentum highlights growing confidence in its ongoing operational transformation.
DK vs. DINO: Price Performance
Both refining stocks have delivered remarkable gains in 2026, reflecting investor optimism surrounding favorable industry fundamentals and strengthening earnings expectations.
DK vs. DINO Share-Price Performance
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
Delek’s shares have surged approximately 131% over the period shown, outperforming HF Sinclair's impressive 121.8% gain.
DK's stronger performance reflects optimism surrounding its operational improvements, improving free cash flow prospects and shareholder-friendly initiatives. Meanwhile, DINO's substantial appreciation underscores confidence in its robust earnings, diversified portfolio and financial strength.
The impressive rallies demonstrate strong investor interest in both refiners.
DK vs. DINO: Valuation Comparison
Despite its stronger stock-price performance, Delek trades at a discount to HF Sinclair based on forward earnings multiples.
DK vs. DINO Forward P/E
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
Delek's 12-month forward price-to-earnings ratio stands at approximately 4.69, compared with HF Sinclair's 5.18, based on the accompanying valuation chart. This represents a discount of approximately 9.5% for DK, suggesting a potentially attractive entry point for investors seeking exposure to improving refining profitability.
HF Sinclair's relatively higher valuation is supported by its larger operating scale, diversified earnings base and strong financial position. Notably, both companies trade at relatively modest earnings multiples, strengthening their appeal to value-oriented investors.
HF Sinclair’s diversified business model and solid liquidity position provide stability, but Delek’s lower forward P/E multiple offers a more attractive entry point. Additionally, its operational streamlining efforts and improving financial flexibility position the company to unlock further value and strengthen free cash flow generation. For investors seeking a combination of value and upside potential, DK appears to be the better pick at current levels.
Image: Bigstock
DK vs. DINO: Which Refining Stock Has the Edge After Q3 Earnings?
Key Takeaways
U.S. refiners Delek US Holdings (DK - Free Report) and HF Sinclair Corporation (DINO - Free Report) delivered impressive third-quarter 2026 results, supported by robust refining margins, favorable market conditions and improved operational performance. Both companies are benefiting from strong industry fundamentals while pursuing initiatives to enhance profitability, strengthen their balance sheets and reward shareholders.
While Delek is gaining momentum from the Enterprise Optimization Plan (“EOP”), HF Sinclair benefits from its diversified operations and considerable financial flexibility. With both stocks delivering exceptional gains this year, let's examine their fundamentals, earnings estimates, price performance and valuations to determine which offers a more compelling investment opportunity.
The Case for Delek US Holdings
Delek reported third-quarter revenues of $4.39 billion, increasing approximately 52% year over year. Adjusted EBITDA surged to $1.28 billion from $766.7 million in the prior-year quarter. Excluding regulatory-related adjustments associated with renewable volume obligations and small refinery exemptions, adjusted EBITDA reached an impressive $1.04 billion.
The company's EOP continues to deliver meaningful improvements. Management raised its annual run-rate free cash flow improvement target to at least $250 million from $220 million. The program contributed approximately $60 million during the quarter, highlighting progress in operational efficiency and refining margin capture.
Delek is also targeting an additional $1-per-barrel net margin improvement at its El Dorado refinery through optimized feedstock selection, product placement and higher-value yields.
Its financial position is strengthening. The company ended September with approximately $1.34 billion in consolidated cash and a standalone net cash position of nearly $22 million, excluding Delek Logistics. Management expects to repay approximately $850 million in term debt during the fourth quarter, supporting lower financing costs.
Additionally, Delek increased the quarterly dividend approximately 18% to 30 cents per share and plans roughly $100 million in fourth-quarter share repurchases, underscoring its commitment to shareholder returns.
The Case for HF Sinclair
HF Sinclair also delivered outstanding third-quarter results, with revenues increasing approximately 50% year over year to $10.86 billion. Adjusted EBITDA surged to $2.98 billion from $870 million a year earlier, while adjusted earnings jumped to $11.75 per share from $2.44.
Its refining segment generated adjusted EBITDA of $2.58 billion, compared with $661 million in the prior-year quarter. Adjusted refinery gross margin improved significantly to $54.22 per produced barrel sold from $19.16, benefiting from strong crack spreads and favorable market dynamics.
HF Sinclair's diversified portfolio provides additional growth opportunities. Its lubricants and specialties segment recorded adjusted EBITDA of $174 million, compared with $78 million a year earlier. Renewable fuels and midstream operations further complement its refining business. The company also maintains a robust financial position, ending September with approximately $3.33 billion in cash against $2.77 billion in debt, translating into net cash of around $559 million. Shareholder returns remain impressive. HF Sinclair returned $572 million to its shareholders through dividends and share repurchases during the quarter and declared a quarterly dividend of 52.5 cents per share.
How Do the Earnings Estimates Compare?
Both refining companies have witnessed substantial upward earnings estimate revisions, highlighting growing analyst confidence in their profitability prospects.
The Zacks Consensus Estimate for Earnings’ Trend
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
Over the past 60 days, the Zacks Consensus Estimate for Delek's 2026 earnings increased 36.98%, from $14.71 to $20.15 per share. HF Sinclair's corresponding earnings estimate climbed 38.12%, from $16.16 to $22.32 per share.
For 2027, Delek's earnings estimate surged 59.60%, while HF Sinclair's increased 57.49%. These encouraging revisions demonstrate strengthening expectations for both companies.
Although HF Sinclair has higher projected earnings per share, Delek's slightly stronger 2027 estimate revision momentum highlights growing confidence in its ongoing operational transformation.
DK vs. DINO: Price Performance
Both refining stocks have delivered remarkable gains in 2026, reflecting investor optimism surrounding favorable industry fundamentals and strengthening earnings expectations.
DK vs. DINO Share-Price Performance
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
Delek’s shares have surged approximately 131% over the period shown, outperforming HF Sinclair's impressive 121.8% gain.
DK's stronger performance reflects optimism surrounding its operational improvements, improving free cash flow prospects and shareholder-friendly initiatives. Meanwhile, DINO's substantial appreciation underscores confidence in its robust earnings, diversified portfolio and financial strength.
The impressive rallies demonstrate strong investor interest in both refiners.
DK vs. DINO: Valuation Comparison
Despite its stronger stock-price performance, Delek trades at a discount to HF Sinclair based on forward earnings multiples.
DK vs. DINO Forward P/E
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
Delek's 12-month forward price-to-earnings ratio stands at approximately 4.69, compared with HF Sinclair's 5.18, based on the accompanying valuation chart. This represents a discount of approximately 9.5% for DK, suggesting a potentially attractive entry point for investors seeking exposure to improving refining profitability.
HF Sinclair's relatively higher valuation is supported by its larger operating scale, diversified earnings base and strong financial position. Notably, both companies trade at relatively modest earnings multiples, strengthening their appeal to value-oriented investors.
Which Refining Stock Is the Better Buy?
Both Delek US Holdings and HF Sinclair currently sport a Zacks Rank #1 (Strong Buy). DK emerges as the more compelling investment choice. You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank stocks here.
HF Sinclair’s diversified business model and solid liquidity position provide stability, but Delek’s lower forward P/E multiple offers a more attractive entry point. Additionally, its operational streamlining efforts and improving financial flexibility position the company to unlock further value and strengthen free cash flow generation. For investors seeking a combination of value and upside potential, DK appears to be the better pick at current levels.