Back to top

Image: Bigstock

AmEx Plunges 13.3% YTD: Is the Selloff an Opportunity or a Warning?

Read MoreHide Full Article

Key Takeaways

  • American Express fell 13.3% YTD, lagging Visa and Mastercard despite resilient card spending and lending.
  • U.S. consumer billings rose 9.4% in Q3, but Card Member services costs surged 36%, limiting margin gains.
  • AmEx saw 99% U.S. Platinum spending retention, while 2026 adjusted EPS guidance stands at $17.60-$17.90.

American Express Company (AXP - Free Report) has lost 13.3% year to date, even as its business continues to grow. The decline is less severe than the broader industry's 19.3% dip, but the contrast with payment peers is stark. Visa Inc. (V - Free Report) and Mastercard Incorporated (MA - Free Report) have gained 21.4% and15.8%, respectively, compared with the S&P 500, which has increased 9.5%. AXP also trades 17.3% below its 52-week high of $387.49.

Has the selloff gone too far, or is the caution justified?

YTD Price Performance – AXP, V, MA, Industry & S&P 500

Zacks Investment Research Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

AmEx’s Valuation

After years of gains, AXP entered 2026 with high expectations. Rising costs, tougher competition and spending concerns have since challenged them. Its forward P/E has slipped to 16.11X, below the five-year median of 16.81X, but remained above the industry's 12.71X. AXP currently carries a Value Score of C.

Zacks Investment Research Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Visa and Mastercard trade at higher multiples of 27.87X and 29.08X, respectively. Unlike those networks, AmEx lends directly to cardholders and bears greater credit risk, partly explaining the gap. Still, Wall Street's average price target of $366 points to room for recovery if confidence returns.

Card Spending Holds Up Despite the Worries

Investors worry that inflation and economic uncertainty will curb discretionary purchases. Yet American Express customers show few signs of pulling back. U.S. consumer billings climbed 9.4% in the third quarter, while international spending increased 11%.

Travel and entertainment spending rose 10%, including 13% airline growth and 9% restaurant growth. Affluent cardholders remain willing to spend on experiences. The question is whether that pace can hold if economic conditions weaken.

Rising Operating Expenses

Stronger spending has not translated into faster profit growth. Third-quarter expenses rose 9%, matching revenue growth. Card Member services costs jumped 36%, while rewards expenses increased 10%. Variable customer engagement expenses accounted for 44.3% of revenues. That leaves little room for margins to improve unless customer benefit costs moderate or revenue accelerates.

Adjusted earnings per share (EPS) increased 13% to $4.68 in the third quarter, but adjusted pretax income grew just 2%. Results included a $215 million benefit from a credit-loss model update and a $195 million discrete tax benefit, although they had no meaningful combined effect. Investors are understandably looking beyond headline earnings to see whether AmEx can expand profits without relying on such benefits or spending more on card perks.

Growing Competition

Commercial billed business grew only 3% in the third quarter, or 5% excluding small-business co-brand portfolio exits. Management acknowledged weaker execution in the middle market, where fintech firms such as Ramp and Brex have popularized automated expense management.

AmEx is responding with corporate cards, software and its Center acquisition, but winning customers will take time. Chase, Capital One and Citi are also competing for affluent consumers with richer rewards, raising the cost of keeping them.

AmEx’s Premium-Card and Lending Businesses Offer Support

The premium-card business offers a brighter picture. Management reported 99% spending retention in the U.S. Platinum portfolio one year after its refresh. Also, AmEx added 3.1 million cards in the third quarter, with 76% of new accounts acquired on fee-paying products. Annual fees can provide more dependable income than transaction-based revenues when spending slows.

Lending provides another growth driver. Card balances and other loans rose 8% to $233.15 billion, while the principal-only net write-off rate eased to 1.8% from 1.9% a year earlier. Credit-loss provisions declined to $985 million from $1.29 billion, although the latest figure included a $211 million model-related reserve release.

AmEx’s Guidance and Zacks Estimates

American Express now expects 2026 adjusted earnings of $17.60-$17.90 per share. The company retained its 10% revenue growth target. Management also aims to sustain mid-teens earnings growth over time.

The Zacks Consensus Estimate for 2026 earnings is pegged at $17.94 per share, slightly above the upper end of management's guidance and indicating 16.6% year-over-year growth. The consensus mark for 2027 EPS signals a further 12.5% increase. Meanwhile, the consensus estimate for 2026 revenues of $79.47 billion indicates a 10% increase, followed by another 8.6% growth in 2027.

AmEx beat earnings estimates three times in the past four quarters and missed once, with the average surprise being 3.3%.

Shareholder Returns Add Another Layer of Support

American Express exited the third quarter with cash & cash equivalents of $43.2 billion, and short-term borrowing was $1.4 billion. Net operating cash flow reached $14.6 billion in the first nine months of 2026. Its solid capital position supports shareholder returns. AmEx repurchased $5.5 billion of shares and distributed $1.9 billion in dividends during the first three quarters of 2026.

What Could Put AXP Back on Track?

A rebound could hinge on AmEx converting Platinum-card investments into sustained fee growth without further inflating rewards costs. Faster middle-market adoption of its new expense-management tools could revive commercial billings, while stable credit quality would protect lending profits. Together, these shifts could restore operating leverage and support valuation expansion.

How to Play AXP Stock Now?

AmEx’s year-to-date decline contrasts with its resilient fundamentals, improving earnings outlook and healthy credit trends. Strong premium-card demand, expanding fee income and consistent shareholder returns reinforce its long-term growth prospects. However, rising customer engagement costs, intensifying competition and sluggish commercial spending warrant caution.

Investors may await clearer signs of operating leverage rather than chasing a rebound. AXP currently carries a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold). You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here.

Published in