Back to top

Image: Bigstock

PayPal Stock Trades at a Discount: Bargain Buy or Value Trap?

Read MoreHide Full Article

Key Takeaways

  • PayPal trades at 10.11 times forward earnings, far below Mastercard and Visa, despite profit gains.
  • Venmo volume rose 14%, Braintree grew 10%, and PayPal raised its 2026 EPS outlook to $5.60.
  • Branded-checkout growth remains at 1-2%, while reinvestment could weigh on near-term margins.

Digital payments remain central to everyday spending, but being an established name no longer guarantees growth. PayPal Holdings, Inc. (PYPL - Free Report) is trying to turn its large consumer and merchant network into a profitable business as competition increases and shopping habits change. This makes its share price worth a closer look.

With PayPal trading at a notable discount, investors face a familiar question: Does the low price offer an opportunity, or does it reflect a business struggling to regain momentum? Venmo, payment processing and consumer financial products provide promising growth avenues. However, weak branded-checkout trends suggest that a turnaround will require time and investment.

Over the past year, its shares declined about 3.9%, while Mastercard (MA - Free Report) has gained 24.2% and Visa (V - Free Report) climbed 32.1%. This performance gap highlights the market's preference for the card networks' steadier growth and raises the stakes for PayPal's recovery plans.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

A More Balanced Business Is Taking Shape at PayPal

PayPal's third-quarter results show why its prospects cannot be judged on checkout alone. Revenues increased 2% year over year to $8.58 billion, while total payment volume rose 6% to $487.1 billion. Non-GAAP earnings per share advanced 8% to $1.45, helped by spending discipline. Transaction margin dollars, an important measure of payment profitability, increased 2% to $4 billion. These results indicate progress, even if the top line remains subdued. 

Venmo is an important part of that progress. Its payment volume increased 14% to $96.8 billion, while monthly active Venmo debit-card accounts rose more than 55% to 6.7 million. Pay with Venmo volume grew 43%. Meanwhile, Braintree's processing volume advanced 10%, supporting PayPal's push into higher-value merchant services. Financial services, including credit, debit and buy now, pay later offerings, already account for more than 20% of transaction margin dollars in 2026 and are growing at a double-digit pace.

PayPal’s Cash Generation Creates Room to Execute

PayPal generated $2 billion in adjusted free cash flow during the third quarter and repurchased $1.5 billion of shares. Management lifted its 2026 non-GAAP earnings outlook to approximately $5.60 per share from $5.38 and now expects at least $6.5 billion in adjusted free cash flow. It also targets at least $1.5 billion in gross annualized cost savings over two to three years. These resources are expected to help fund product improvements and shareholder returns without relying solely on faster revenue growth.

PYPL’s Earnings Estimate Revision Trends Upward

PayPal’s estimate revisions reflect a favorable trend for 2026 and 2027. The Zacks Consensus Estimate for 2026 and 2027 EPS also implies a 4.90% and 5.93% year-over-year increase, respectively.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

The Checkout Challenge Has Not Disappeared for PayPal

The main concern is online branded checkout, where currency-neutral payment-volume growth was just 1% in the third quarter. Growth has remained around 1-2% for four consecutive quarters. Management sees improvement among selected U.S. merchants, but European tariff-related disruptions and persistent competition are slowing the broader recovery. 

Planned spending on checkout experience, customer engagement and international expansion may improve results but could limit near-term margin gains. Management is targeting 2027 non-GAAP EPS growth broadly similar to that of 2026 while it continues investing. Management is evaluating branded-checkout investments over a two-to-three-year horizon, with initiatives involving its largest merchants expected to require closer to three years.

Is the Valuation Discount Justified for PayPal?

PayPal shares are trading cheap, as suggested by the Value Score of A. On a forward 12-month P/E basis, PayPal trades at roughly 10.11 times earnings, compared with 29.08 times for Mastercard and 27.87 times for Visa. 

Mastercard and Visa operate extensive card networks with stronger margins, while PayPal faces more direct competition in digital checkout and merchant processing. A lower multiple offers some cushion if earnings remain stable; however, a lasting revaluation likely depends on healthier checkout growth and sustained transaction-margin improvement. 

Valuation: Forward 12-month P/E

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

What Should Investors Do With PYPL Stock?

PayPal's current price reflects investors’ skepticism, but its operations also show encouraging signs. Venmo adoption, Braintree momentum, cash generation and cost savings give management several ways to improve earnings without depending entirely on branded checkout. 

Still, the company must prove that its investments can revive consumer engagement and deliver stronger transaction margins. The wide valuation discount to Mastercard and Visa makes the shares worth following rather than automatically signaling a bargain. For investors already exposed to PYPL, maintaining their positions while watching branded-checkout trends, execution against guidance and the pace of reinvestment appears more sensible than rushing to increase exposure.

PayPal currently carries a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold). You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here.

Published in