Back to top

Image: Bigstock

Walmart or Dollar General: Which Stock Should Investors Favor?

Read MoreHide Full Article

Key Takeaways

  • Walmart's scale, digital growth and expanding membership ecosystem strengthen its retail position.
  • Dollar General benefits from rising traffic, store upgrades and improving operational efficiency.
  • Both stocks have outpaced the retail sector and trade below their respective historical median valuations.

Walmart Inc. (WMT - Free Report) and Dollar General Corporation (DG - Free Report) are established players in the discount retail space, serving shoppers who prioritize affordability, accessibility and convenience. While Walmart combines its extensive store network with a growing digital ecosystem and membership offerings, Dollar General primarily relies on its neighborhood-focused retail model to serve customers in rural and smaller communities.

With households remaining mindful of everyday expenses, both retailers are refining their strategies to strengthen customer engagement and capture additional market share. Walmart, with a market capitalization of approximately $986.5 billion, operates on a significantly larger scale than Dollar General, valued at roughly $29.5 billion. However, their different growth strategies, operating performance and earnings expectations make for an interesting investment comparison.

The Case for Walmart

Walmart's competitive strength stems from its extensive retail footprint, broad product assortment and ability to offer attractive prices across multiple shopping channels. Its integrated approach to physical stores, online shopping and membership services allows customers to access everyday necessities conveniently. The company's focus on affordability, faster fulfillment and customer experience continues to support market share gains and strengthen its position across diverse consumer income groups.

Digital expansion remains an important growth catalyst for Walmart. During the second quarter of fiscal 2027, global e-commerce sales increased 23%, benefiting from marketplace growth and store-fulfilled pickup and delivery. Its global advertising business expanded 38%, while membership fee revenues rose 17%. These businesses are becoming increasingly important contributors to Walmart's operating model, offering opportunities to improve profitability through a more favorable business mix and deeper customer engagement.

Walmart is also investing in automation, artificial intelligence and supply-chain capabilities to enhance productivity and fulfillment efficiency. Its growing digital infrastructure supports faster deliveries, improved inventory management and personalized shopping experiences. Encouraged by its business performance, management raised its fiscal 2027 net sales growth guidance to 4-5% and adjusted operating income growth outlook to 7-8.5%, both on a constant-currency basis. These expectations underscore management's confidence in its diversified operating model.

However, Walmart faces pressure from continued price investments, higher depreciation expenses, insurance-related costs and employee healthcare spending. Although second-quarter profitability improved, the results also benefited from tariff refunds, making underlying earnings trends important to monitor. Nevertheless, the company's strong retail foundation, expanding digital capabilities and growing higher-margin businesses provide meaningful opportunities for sustained growth.

The Case for Dollar General

Dollar General's value-oriented merchandise assortment and convenient store locations remain central to its competitive advantage. Its substantial presence in rural and underserved communities enables shoppers to purchase everyday essentials without traveling long distances. The company's emphasis on affordable products, accessible price points and neighborhood convenience resonates with financially constrained households and supports its ability to attract value-conscious consumers.

Dollar General's recent results indicate improving business execution and customer engagement. In the second quarter of fiscal 2026, same-store sales advanced 3.5%, reflecting a 2% increase in customer traffic and a 1.5% rise in average transaction value. All four merchandise categories delivered positive comparable sales growth for the sixth consecutive quarter. Continued improvements in shrink, damages and inventory management also reflect progress in operational discipline and store-level productivity.

Store modernization is another important component of Dollar General's growth strategy. Through Project Renovate and Project Elevate, the company is upgrading existing locations, improving merchandise displays and enhancing shopping convenience. Management continues to target an annualized comparable-sales lift of approximately 6% for Project Renovate stores and 3% for Project Elevate locations, highlighting the potential benefits of these initiatives. Meanwhile, expanding delivery services, digital engagement and the DG Media Network are creating additional opportunities to attract customers and support profitable sales growth.

Reflecting stronger first-half results and an improved business outlook, Dollar General raised its fiscal 2026 financial guidance. Management now expects net sales growth of 4-4.3%, same-store sales growth of 2.5-2.9% and earnings per share of $7.80-$8.00. Although higher fuel and transportation costs, competitive pricing and cautious consumer spending remain challenges, improvements in merchandising, store execution and cost management could support further operating gains. The company's recent profitability also benefited from tariff refunds, making continued underlying margin improvement important for its longer-term performance.

WMT vs. DG: What Do Earnings Estimates Suggest?

Estimates for Walmart's earnings have remained largely unchanged over the past month, indicating stable expectations for its financial performance. The Zacks Consensus Estimate for the current fiscal year has held steady at $2.88 per share over the past 30 days, suggesting year-over-year growth of 9.1%. Similarly, the consensus estimate for the next fiscal year has remained unchanged at $3.22 per share, implying growth of around 12%.
 

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Dollar General, meanwhile, has witnessed favorable earnings-estimate revisions, suggesting improving expectations for its financial performance. Over the past 30 days, the Zacks Consensus Estimate for the current fiscal year has increased to $7.95 per share, calling for a jump of 16.1% year over year. The consensus estimate for the next fiscal year has also moved higher to $8.41 per share, implying growth of 5.8%.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

WMT vs. DG: Which Stock Has Performed Better?

Shares of DG have rallied 29.2%, while Walmart has gained 25.8%. Both stocks have outperformed the Zacks Retail – Wholesale sector, which has risen 7.5% during the same period.
 

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Dollar General's stronger share price performance has coincided with improving operating trends and progress across its strategic initiatives. Meanwhile, Walmart's positive returns reflect the continued resilience of its business model and expanding opportunities across digital retailing.

WMT vs. DG: How Do Their Valuations Compare?

From a valuation standpoint, Walmart currently trades at a forward 12-month price-to-earnings (P/E) multiple of 40.48, below its one-year median of 48.55. Dollar General's forward 12-month P/E of 16.06 also stands below its one-year median of 22.94. This indicates that both stocks are trading at discounts to their respective recent historical valuation levels.
 

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

However, Dollar General commands a substantially lower earnings multiple than Walmart. While this gap reflects differences in business scale, growth prospects and risk profiles, DG's relatively modest valuation, alongside improving operating trends and favorable earnings revisions, strengthens its appeal in this comparison.

WMT vs. DG: Which Stock Looks More Promising?

Both Walmart and Dollar General offer compelling opportunities in value retailing. Walmart's extensive scale, expanding digital ecosystem and diversified revenue streams provide a strong foundation for long-term growth. However, Dollar General appears more attractive at present, supported by improving customer traffic, broad-based category gains and stronger operational execution. Its store modernization initiatives and digital expansion efforts offer additional growth opportunities. Favorable earnings-estimate revisions, stronger share price momentum and a significantly lower valuation currently give DG an edge over Walmart despite ongoing cost pressures and cautious consumer spending.

WMT currently carries a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold), whereas DG has a Zacks Rank of 2 (Buy). You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here.

Published in