We use cookies to understand how you use our site and to improve your experience.
This includes personalizing content and advertising.
By pressing "Accept All" or closing out of this banner, you consent to the use of all cookies and similar technologies and the sharing of information they collect with third parties.
You can reject marketing cookies by pressing "Deny Optional," but we still use essential, performance, and functional cookies.
In addition, whether you "Accept All," Deny Optional," click the X or otherwise continue to use the site, you accept our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service, revised from time to time.
You are being directed to ZacksTrade, a division of LBMZ Securities and licensed broker-dealer. ZacksTrade and Zacks.com are separate companies. The web link between the two companies is not a solicitation or offer to invest in a particular security or type of security. ZacksTrade does not endorse or adopt any particular investment strategy, any analyst opinion/rating/report or any approach to evaluating individual securities.
If you wish to go to ZacksTrade, click OK. If you do not, click Cancel.
Valero Energy vs. Phillips 66: Which is the Stronger Refining Player?
Read MoreHide Full Article
Key Takeaways
Valero outperformed Phillips 66 with a 111.1% YTD gain versus PSX's 89.7% advance.
VLO's access to discounted heavy-sour crude supports feedstock cost optimization.
VLO holds $1.2 billion in net cash and trades at 4.34x EV/EBITDA versus PSX's 6.78x.
The energy sector still holds the top spot, with oil prices remaining high, though they have fallen significantly from the $100-per-barrel mark. This implies that raw material costs for refiners remain elevated. So, what lies ahead for refiners like Phillips 66 (PSX - Free Report) and Valero Energy Corporation (VLO - Free Report) ?
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
To answer this question, let’s first examine how the two stocks have performed. Year to date, VLO has surged 111.1%, outperforming PSX’s 89.7% gain. However, stronger share price performance does not necessarily make VLO a better investment than PSX. Before concluding, let’s analyze the broader business environment.
Broader Global Refining Business Environment
Per the International Energy Agency, global refineries processed 1.3 million fewer barrels of crude per day in October 2026, bringing activity to 81.3 million barrels per day, but output is expected to recover to 84.7 million by December and average 84.3 million in 2027, up 2.5 million after a 2.2-million decline in 2026.
Refining profits weakened across most regions in October, as record-high shipping costs increased expenses for Asian refiners. U.S. refiners benefited from cheaper crude oil, but lower gasoline selling prices reduced their profit margins. This reflects the broader refining business environment for leading energy players like PSX and VLO.
Let’s delve into the companies’ fundamentals in more detail.
VLO’s Greater Flexibility to Favorable Crude Feedstock Economics
VLO benefits from its strategically located Gulf Coast refining system, which provides access to a wide range of crude grades and competitively priced feedstocks. Higher freight costs have widened discounts on several crude grades, creating opportunities for Gulf Coast refiners. VLO also achieved a new processing record for Venezuelan crude during the third quarter of 2026.
Its ability to switch between different crude grades provides an important competitive advantage and helps optimize feedstock costs.
PSX also benefits from access to discounted Canadian crude, importing more Canadian crude into the United States than any other company. However, VLO's demonstrated flexibility across Canadian, Venezuelan and other heavy-sour crude grades provides a compelling feedstock optimization advantage.
VLO’s Stronger Balance Sheet and Greater Financial Flexibility
VLO has a significantly stronger balance sheet, providing greater flexibility to navigate volatile commodity markets and return cash to shareholders. At the end of third-quarter 2026, VLO had $9.8 billion in cash against $8.6 billion in total debt, resulting in a net cash position of approximately $1.2 billion, excluding finance lease obligations. Its net debt-to-capitalization ratio was just 4%.
In comparison, PSX reported $18.5 billion in total debt and $12.7 billion in net debt, with a net debt-to-capitalization ratio of 26%. Although PSX reduced debt by $2 billion during the quarter, its leverage remains considerably higher than VLO's.
VLO vs PSX: Which is the Better Stock?
Before concluding which stock is better, let's have a look at the valuation picture. In terms of valuation, VLO appears relatively cheap, trading at a trailing 12-month EV/EBITDA of 4.34x, a discount to PSX’s 6.78x.
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research
Thus, it has become evident that despite the strong share price appreciation, reflected in the chart above, VLO still appears undervalued. Hence, investors should grab this opportunity to bet on the stock having better financial flexibility and greater flexibility to favorable crude feedstock economics. Currently, VLO carries a Zacks Rank #2 (Buy).
Image: Bigstock
Valero Energy vs. Phillips 66: Which is the Stronger Refining Player?
Key Takeaways
The energy sector still holds the top spot, with oil prices remaining high, though they have fallen significantly from the $100-per-barrel mark. This implies that raw material costs for refiners remain elevated. So, what lies ahead for refiners like Phillips 66 (PSX - Free Report) and Valero Energy Corporation (VLO - Free Report) ?
To answer this question, let’s first examine how the two stocks have performed. Year to date, VLO has surged 111.1%, outperforming PSX’s 89.7% gain. However, stronger share price performance does not necessarily make VLO a better investment than PSX. Before concluding, let’s analyze the broader business environment.
Broader Global Refining Business Environment
Per the International Energy Agency, global refineries processed 1.3 million fewer barrels of crude per day in October 2026, bringing activity to 81.3 million barrels per day, but output is expected to recover to 84.7 million by December and average 84.3 million in 2027, up 2.5 million after a 2.2-million decline in 2026.
Refining profits weakened across most regions in October, as record-high shipping costs increased expenses for Asian refiners. U.S. refiners benefited from cheaper crude oil, but lower gasoline selling prices reduced their profit margins. This reflects the broader refining business environment for leading energy players like PSX and VLO.
Let’s delve into the companies’ fundamentals in more detail.
VLO’s Greater Flexibility to Favorable Crude Feedstock Economics
VLO benefits from its strategically located Gulf Coast refining system, which provides access to a wide range of crude grades and competitively priced feedstocks. Higher freight costs have widened discounts on several crude grades, creating opportunities for Gulf Coast refiners. VLO also achieved a new processing record for Venezuelan crude during the third quarter of 2026.
Its ability to switch between different crude grades provides an important competitive advantage and helps optimize feedstock costs.
PSX also benefits from access to discounted Canadian crude, importing more Canadian crude into the United States than any other company. However, VLO's demonstrated flexibility across Canadian, Venezuelan and other heavy-sour crude grades provides a compelling feedstock optimization advantage.
VLO’s Stronger Balance Sheet and Greater Financial Flexibility
VLO has a significantly stronger balance sheet, providing greater flexibility to navigate volatile commodity markets and return cash to shareholders. At the end of third-quarter 2026, VLO had $9.8 billion in cash against $8.6 billion in total debt, resulting in a net cash position of approximately $1.2 billion, excluding finance lease obligations. Its net debt-to-capitalization ratio was just 4%.
In comparison, PSX reported $18.5 billion in total debt and $12.7 billion in net debt, with a net debt-to-capitalization ratio of 26%. Although PSX reduced debt by $2 billion during the quarter, its leverage remains considerably higher than VLO's.
VLO vs PSX: Which is the Better Stock?
Before concluding which stock is better, let's have a look at the valuation picture. In terms of valuation, VLO appears relatively cheap, trading at a trailing 12-month EV/EBITDA of 4.34x, a discount to PSX’s 6.78x.
Thus, it has become evident that despite the strong share price appreciation, reflected in the chart above, VLO still appears undervalued. Hence, investors should grab this opportunity to bet on the stock having better financial flexibility and greater flexibility to favorable crude feedstock economics. Currently, VLO carries a Zacks Rank #2 (Buy).
On the other hand, those who have already invested in PSX may retain the stock, which carries a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold). You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here.