Back to top

Image: Bigstock

NetApp vs. Dell: Which AI Data Storage Stock is the Better Buy?

Read MoreHide Full Article

Key Takeaways

  • NetApp and Dell benefit from rising AI storage demand, but their growth, valuations and stock returns differ.
  • NTAP surged 44.7% in six months versus DELL's 28%, but trades at a higher forward P/E of 16.26 versus 10.65.
  • Dell's AI backlog hit $95 billion, while its earnings estimates rose and NetApp's remained unchanged.

NetApp, Inc. (NTAP - Free Report) and Dell Technologies Inc. (DELL - Free Report) are benefiting from the growing adoption of AI, increasing data storage requirements and ongoing enterprise infrastructure modernization. As organizations accelerate AI deployments, the need for high-performance, scalable and secure storage solutions continues to rise. Enterprises are increasingly investing in modernizing their data infrastructure to efficiently manage growing data volumes, support AI-driven workloads and strengthen data security. These trends are creating significant growth opportunities for both companies, which are expanding their capabilities to capitalize on the rising demand for AI-ready storage infrastructure.

NetApp is gaining from strong demand for its all-flash arrays, hybrid cloud storage solutions and AI-ready data infrastructure, supported by growing adoption of its unified data platform and cloud services. Dell, meanwhile, is benefiting from robust demand for its proprietary storage portfolio, including PowerStore, PowerScale, ObjectScale and PowerFlex, alongside increasing AI infrastructure investments. Both companies are witnessing improving storage demand and expanding opportunities as enterprises modernize their IT environments. However, rising component costs and evolving customer spending patterns remain important considerations.

Against this backdrop, which of these two AI data storage stocks, NTAP or DELL, offers a more compelling investment opportunity?

The Case for NTAP

NetApp is gaining from robust demand for AI-driven data infrastructure and storage modernization solutions. In the first quarter of fiscal 2027, the company secured approximately 350 AI and data lake modernization deals, with deal sizes increasing as customers transitioned from pilot projects to production environments. Significant agreements with Samsung Electronics, a public-sector organization and an Asian neocloud provider, underscore its expanding presence in AI infrastructure. The NetApp Platform enables enterprises to make data AI-ready without costly data movement, supporting high-performance analytics and AI workloads. Growing enterprise investments in AI and infrastructure modernization are expected to sustain demand for its offerings.

The company is benefiting from strong adoption of its all-flash storage and hybrid cloud solutions. All-flash array revenues surged 47% year over year to $1.31 billion in the fiscal first quarter, supported by demand for high-performance, low-latency storage. Public Cloud revenues increased 28% to $206 million, driven by first-party and marketplace storage services. Growing VMware workload migrations to cloud platforms are creating additional opportunities for Amazon FSx for NetApp ONTAP and Azure NetApp Files. Meanwhile, rising interest in hybrid flash solutions and continued momentum in Keystone storage-as-a-service offerings further strengthen its growth prospects.

NetApp's strategic acquisitions are enhancing its competitive position in AI and cloud infrastructure. The buyout of DataPelago strengthens its AI data processing capabilities by enabling high-performance, in-place processing of unstructured data without unnecessary movement. The JetStream acquisition, completed at the beginning of second-quarter fiscal 2027, expands its cloud-native disaster recovery capabilities for VMware environments. These investments are expected to broaden NetApp's addressable market, improve product differentiation and strengthen customer engagement.

Recently, NetApp completed the acquisition of PEAK:AIO to enhance its AI storage capabilities and develop NetApp Novus, a zettabyte-scale storage architecture designed to support demanding AI workloads and improve GPU efficiency.

Strong financial execution and an improved outlook are additional positives. Fiscal first-quarter revenues increased 30% year over year to $2.03 billion, while non-GAAP earnings surged 66% to $2.58 per share. Non-GAAP operating margin expanded 610 basis points (bps) to 31.9%. Encouraged by broad-based demand, management raised its fiscal 2027 revenue guidance to $7.98-$8.23 billion and non-GAAP EPS guidance to $9.73-$10.03. Strong cash generation, including $401 million in quarterly free cash flow, further supports financial flexibility.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

However, NetApp is grappling with rising component costs and an unfavorable revenue mix, which are pressuring margins. Fiscal first-quarter non-GAAP product gross margin declined 150 bps sequentially to 54.6%, primarily due to higher component costs, partially offset by improved pricing. Overall gross margin contracted 50 bps year over year to 70.6%, reflecting a greater contribution from lower-margin product revenues. Management expects second-quarter gross margin to decline further to 67-68%, highlighting continued profitability pressures.

The company also faces challenges from higher operating expenses and changing customer purchasing patterns. Fiscal first-quarter operating expenses increased 11% year over year to $784 million, reflecting higher variable compensation and the additional reporting week. Continued investments in AI solutions could add to expenses. Moreover, rising prices are prompting some customers to defer lower-priority projects or shift toward hybrid flash alternatives. Accelerated purchases by certain large customers also introduce uncertainty regarding the timing and sustainability of future demand.

The Case for DELL

Dell Technologies is gaining from accelerating demand for AI infrastructure, supported by growing investments from neocloud, sovereign and enterprise customers. In the second quarter of fiscal 2027, the company recorded $60.9 billion in AI server orders and generated $16.4 billion in AI server revenues. Its AI backlog reached a record $95 billion, while the customer base surpassed 6,500. Dell's engineering expertise, global supply chain and deployment capabilities are strengthening its competitive position. The company expects AI server revenues to triple year over year to $74 billion in fiscal 2027.

The company is benefiting from sustained demand for traditional servers as enterprises modernize aging data centers to improve performance, efficiency and security. Traditional server and networking revenues surged 122% to $10.5 billion in the fiscal second quarter. Dell gained more than 10 percentage points of traditional server market share over the past two quarters. With a significant portion of its installed base still running on older-generation servers, the company sees considerable refresh opportunities. Growing adoption of agentic AI workloads is providing additional demand momentum.

Dell's storage business is gaining traction, driven by growing data volumes, infrastructure modernization and emerging AI-related requirements. Storage revenues increased 26% to $4.9 billion in the fiscal second quarter. Demand for its proprietary Dell IP storage portfolio exceeded market growth for six consecutive quarters. Strong performance across PowerFlex, PowerStore, PowerProtect and PowerVault, alongside expanding demand for unstructured storage solutions, is encouraging. An increasing contribution from higher-margin Dell IP offerings is also strengthening storage profitability and supporting overall Infrastructure Solutions Group margins.

The company is benefiting from improving demand across its Client Solutions Group (CSG), particularly among commercial customers undertaking PC refresh initiatives. CSG revenues increased 20% to $15 billion in the fiscal second quarter, with commercial revenues rising 22% to $13.2 billion, marking the eighth consecutive quarter of growth. Consumer revenues increased 7% to $1.8 billion. Dell's disciplined pricing strategy, operating efficiencies and enterprise customer relationships are supporting profitability. The growing installed base of older PCs also presents a meaningful long-term replacement opportunity.

Dell's financial performance is strengthening, supported by robust revenue growth, operating leverage and disciplined execution. Fiscal second-quarter revenues surged 58% to $47 billion, while non-GAAP earnings per share increased 203% to $7.04. Operating income climbed 160% to $5.9 billion. Encouraged by broad-based demand, management raised its fiscal 2027 revenue guidance by $25 billion to $192 billion and expects non-GAAP earnings of $25.50 per share. Continued operational modernization and improving scale are expected to support profitability.

However, Dell is grappling with persistent supply-chain constraints and rising component costs, which could limit its ability to fulfill strong customer demand. Shortages of DRAM, NAND, CPUs and other critical components are restricting shipments, while inflationary pressures are increasing product costs. Additionally, price-sensitive customers are extending upgrade cycles, and management expects CSG operating margins to moderate to approximately 6% in the third quarter. These challenges could weigh on near-term growth and profitability.

Share Price Trajectory for NTAP & DELL

Over the past six months, NTAP stock has soared 44.7% while DELL grew 28.9%.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Valuation Comparison

Going by the price/earnings ratio, NTAP’s shares currently trade at 16.26 forward earnings, higher than 10.65 for DELL.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

How Do Zacks Estimates Compare for NTAP & DELL?

For the current year, earnings estimates for NTAP’s bottom line have remained unchanged.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

The Zacks Consensus Estimate for DELL’s earnings has increased marginally over the past 60 days.

Zacks Investment Research
Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

NTAP or DELL: Which Stock Deserves Investors’ Attention Now?

Dell appears to be the better investment choice at present, supported by its Zacks Rank #2 (Buy), lower valuation and positive earnings estimate revisions. In contrast, NetApp carries a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold), making DELL a more attractive pick for investors seeking exposure to AI-driven infrastructure growth.

You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 (Strong Buy) Rank stocks here.

Published in