Moody’s Investors Service, the rating arm of Moody's Corporation (MCO - Free Report) , recently announced that it downgraded the outlook for E*TRADE Financial (ETFC - Free Report) to negative from stable and that of Charles Schwab (SCHW - Free Report) to stable from positive. This came in after the brokerage firms announced that they are eliminating commissions for stocks, ETFs and options trades, hence, joining Interactive Brokers (IBKR - Free Report) in the price war.
TD Ameritrade Holding (AMTD - Free Report) , which also announced commission-free trading, did not witness any change in its outlook and the same remained stable.
However, the ratings of the three firms were not changed. Moody's affirmed their ratings.
The issuer as well as senior unsecured debt ratings of E*TRADE Financial has been affirmed at Baa2. The senior unsecured debt rating of Schwab has been affirmed at A2 while its commercial paper rating has been affirmed at P-1. Moreover, TD Ameritrade’s issuer as well as senior unsecured debt ratings has also been affirmed at A2.
Reason Behind the Change in Outlook
Per Moody’s, relatively lower interest rates and flattening of the yield curve are already adversely impacting financials of brokerage firms. Now, with this fee cut, the profitability of these firms will likely be hurt even more. This is the main reason why Moody’s downgraded the outlook for these firms.
From charging $4.95-$6.95 per trade to zero commissions, these brokerage firms will be foregoing substantial fees.
Schwab estimates that zero-commission trades are likely to have 3-4% adverse impact on quarterly net revenues while TD Ameritrade’s net revenues will likely decline 15-16%. E*TRADE Financial estimates that this move will have a 10% adverse impact on its net revenues.
Notably, Schwab seems to be a bit better positioned than its peers because it is less dependent on commissions, which constitute roughly 7% of total revenues. However, E*TRADE Financial’s smaller scale compared with its peers puts it in a competitively disadvantageous position, making it difficult for it to be able to attract new clients.
Moreover, while commission-free trading is expected to adversely impact TD Ameritrade’s revenue growth, it will be partially offset by the company’s cost-saving efforts.
Reasons Behind the Ratings Affirmation
Moody’s affirmed the ratings of E*TRADE Financial because it believes that the company’s credit profile has improved over the past few years. This has benefited from the firm’s balance sheet expansion strategy. Moreover, the company is well positioned to accommodate a growing client base while maintaining a strong leverage ratio.
Coming to Schwab, over the past few years, it has witnessed a significant improvement in its pre-tax margin, aided by rising equity market values and net client inflows, per Moody’s. Its planned acquisition of USAA’s Investment Management Company, efforts to strengthen trading business and improvement in operating efficiency bode well for the future.
The reason behind the ratings affirmation for TD Ameritrade is that it has a strong franchise in the online brokerage business, with clear leadership in the active trader segment and the growing institutional business, serving registered investment advisors. In fact, the company’s acquisition of Scottrade Financial Services in 2017 significantly enhanced its scale and competitive position, without significantly increasing leverage.
Currently, Schwab and TD Ameritrade carry a Zacks Rank #5 (Strong Sell) while E*TRADE Financial has a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold).
You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here.
Today's Best Stocks from Zacks
Would you like to see the updated picks from our best market-beating strategies? From 2017 through 2018, while the S&P 500 gained +15.8%, five of our screens returned +38.0%, +61.3%, +61.6%, +68.1%, and +98.3%.
This outperformance has not just been a recent phenomenon. From 2000 – 2018, while the S&P averaged +4.8% per year, our top strategies averaged up to +56.2% per year.
See their latest picks free >>