Member Sign In

When deciding whether to sell your home or rent it out, market trends and personal goals usually take center stage. However, the tax implications can be just as important and often tip the scales. Selling a primary residence comes with generous tax breaks that you may lose if you turn it into a rental. On the other hand, holding it as a rental gives you steady deductions that can reduce your taxable income for years.

Understanding these trade-offs can help you avoid an expensive surprise and make a smarter decision about your property.

The Tax Perks of Selling Your Home

If the house has been your primary residence for at least two of the past five years, the IRS allows you to exclude up to $250,000 in capital gains if you’re single, or $500,000 if you’re married filing jointly. That means if you bought your home for $300,000 and sell it for $600,000, you could pocket most or all of that gain tax-free.

This is one of the most generous tax breaks available to homeowners. The catch? Once the property becomes a rental, you may lose access to this exclusion. Waiting too long to sell could mean facing a hefty capital gains bill later.

Selling also comes with upfront costs like realtor commissions and closing fees, but for many owners sitting on years of appreciation, the ability to lock in tax-free gains makes selling the cleaner option.

How Renting Works for Taxes

Turning your home into a rental shifts the tax picture. Rental income is taxable, but landlords can offset much of it through deductions. You can write off mortgage interest, property taxes, repairs, insurance, property management fees and even depreciation. These deductions often reduce or sometimes even eliminate your taxable rental income.

Depreciation is particularly powerful. The IRS lets you deduct a portion of your home’s value every year as if it were wearing out, even if it’s actually appreciating. Over time, this can add up to significant tax savings.

However, there’s a trade-off. Depreciation deductions lower your cost basis in the property. When you eventually sell, the IRS will “recapture” that depreciation, taxing it at up to 25%. You’ll also owe capital gains tax on the appreciation unless you use strategies like a 1031 exchange.

Capital Gains and Rental Properties

If you keep the house as a rental and later decide to sell, the gain is treated differently from a primary residence. Without the home-sale exclusion, you’ll likely owe capital gains tax. For long-term holdings (over a year), the rate ranges from 0% to 20% depending on income. Short-term gains (within a year) are taxed as ordinary income, which can be much higher.

There are ways to soften the blow:

Convert the rental back into a primary residence for two years before selling.

Use a 1031 exchange to reinvest profits into another rental property and defer taxes.

Sell in a lower-income year to reduce the tax bracket you fall into.

Offset gains with losses through tax-loss harvesting or by deducting eligible expenses.

These strategies require planning, but they can significantly reduce the tax hit when selling a rental.

The Bigger Picture

Taxes aren’t the only factor. Renting brings ongoing responsibilities, like dealing with tenants and repairs, unless you hire a management company. Selling frees you from those headaches but ends the chance of ongoing cash flow and future appreciation.

But when it comes to purely financial outcomes, taxes can be the hidden swing factor. Selling now could mean walking away with a large tax-free profit. Renting could build long-term wealth through deductions and appreciation but may saddle you with a future tax bill if you don’t plan carefully.

Bottom Line

If you want a clean exit and can qualify for the home-sale tax exclusion, selling might be the smarter financial move. If you prefer a steady income and are comfortable managing a rental —or hiring someone to do it — renting offers powerful ongoing deductions, with the caveat that you’ll eventually face capital gains taxes.

Either way, the decision deserves a careful look at both your short-term needs and long-term tax exposure. Consulting a tax professional before you make your move can save you thousands of dollars down the road.