Restaurant operators are navigating a mixed consumer spending backdrop, higher labor and input costs and the ongoing need to refresh concepts to sustain traffic. In this environment, Ark Restaurants Corp. (ARKR Quick QuoteARKR - Free Report) and Flanigan’s Enterprises, Inc. (BDL Quick QuoteBDL - Free Report) stand out as two niche players with distinct operating models. ARKR runs a portfolio of destination, high-traffic restaurants and food concepts across major tourist and urban markets, while BDL operates and franchises a long-established Florida-focused casual dining and package liquor store network.

Ark Restaurants’ model benefits from premium locations and event-driven demand, but it also carries meaningful site-specific risk. Flanigan’s continues to emphasize standardized neighborhood casual dining, loyalty-driven traffic and a diversified revenue base that includes high-volume liquor retail — a structure that can provide steadier local demand but remains exposed to Florida’s competitive labor and pricing environment. With both companies operating in the same broader restaurant-and-bars industry but pursuing very different scales, geography and risk profiles, the key question is: which stock looks more compelling right now? Let’s take a closer look.

Stock Performance & Valuation: BDL vs. ARKR

BDL (down 7.2%) has outperformed ARKR (down 10.5%) over the past three months. In the past year, Flanigan’s has rallied 16.1% against Ark Restaurants loss of 43.1%.

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Meanwhile, BDL is trading at a trailing 12-month enterprise value-to-sales (EV/S) ratio of 0.26X, in line with its median over the past five years. ARKR’s forward sales multiple sits at 0.08X, below its last five-year median of 0.28X. BDL and ARKR both appear to be cheap when compared with the Retail-Wholesale sector average of 1.82X.

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Factors Driving Flanigan’s Stock

Flanigan’s is being supported by a business model that blends casual dining with high-volume liquor retail, giving the company multiple demand drivers and helping smooth performance across different consumer spending environments. The company operates restaurant concepts under the Flanigan’s Seafood Bar and Grill brand alongside its Big Daddy’s Liquors stores, allowing it to capture both dine-in occasions and off-premise alcohol purchases through a diversified revenue base. This dual-segment structure is reinforced by BDL’s long-standing local presence in Florida, where brand familiarity and repeat traffic play an important role in sustaining demand across its footprint.

Another key factor is Flanigan’s ownership and operating structure, which supports expansion while maintaining operational control. In addition to company-owned units, the firm operates through affiliated limited partnerships where it often serves as the sole general partner. This setup enables BDL to influence decision-making across the network while also generating recurring economics through management fees and royalties tied to the use of its brands.

Finally, the stock has been supported by steady sales momentum, with fiscal 2025 revenue growth driven by higher restaurant and package store sales. Flanigan’s benefited from menu price increases and improved performance across both operating segments, reinforcing its ability to preserve top-line growth even amid cost and pricing pressures.

Factors Driving Ark Restaurants Stock

Ark Restaurants is being supported by a business model built around high-traffic, destination-oriented venues that benefit from strong location economics and steady demand tied to tourism, entertainment and dense urban footfall. The company operates a portfolio spanning full-service restaurants, bars and fast-food concepts across markets like New York City, Las Vegas, Atlantic City and Washington, D.C., with many units positioned in major commercial and visitor hubs. This footprint provides ARKR with a differentiated demand profile versus traditional casual dining, as sales are often driven by event activity, travel flows and premium site exposure rather than purely neighborhood traffic.

Another factor is Ark Restaurants’ long-running acquisition and concept expansion strategy, which has been central to how the company has built scale. Management has historically grown by acquiring and operating established venues and hospitality concepts, allowing the firm to diversify across formats — including restaurants, bars, fast food and catering — while leveraging its operational expertise across a broader base. This approach has enabled ARKR to maintain a varied portfolio that can capture demand across multiple dining occasions and customer segments.

A third key driver for Ark Restaurants is the high revenue concentration in a few flagship, destination venues, which makes developments tied to these assets especially influential for investor sentiment. The company highlighted that its Bryant Park Grill & Café and The Porch at Bryant Park leases expired in 2025, and these two locations accounted for a meaningful share of total fiscal 2025 revenue. As a result, the market is closely watching how management navigates the future of these high-profile sites, since any resolution — including renewals, revised terms or changes in operating status — could materially shape ARKR’s revenue mix, visibility and longer-term operating outlook.

Choose BDL Over ARKR Now

While both Ark Restaurants and Flanigan’s Enterprises operate in the broader restaurant-and-bars space, their fundamentals reflect two very different investment profiles. Ark Restaurants’ portfolio is built around destination-driven venues in premium, high-traffic markets, supported by a mix of full-service restaurants, bars and fast-food concepts across major tourist and urban hubs. This gives ARKR exposure to event- and travel-linked demand, but also creates greater sensitivity to location-specific developments, especially when a meaningful portion of revenue is tied to a handful of marquee assets.

Flanigan’s, on the other hand, offers a more stable, Florida-focused operating model, supported by its diversified structure spanning casual dining and high-volume liquor retail. The company’s standardized neighborhood format, long-standing local brand presence and dual revenue streams provide steadier demand drivers, while its partnership-based ownership structure helps it expand while maintaining operational control and recurring economics through fees and royalties. For investors prioritizing consistency and a diversified local demand base, Flanigan’s appears to be the more compelling pick, while Ark Restaurants remains better suited for those comfortable with higher site-level concentration risk tied to key flagship venues.