Member Sign In

An extra $75 a month? Who wouldn't want that?

That's about $900 more a year for groceries, utilities, and prescriptions, or maybe something a little more enjoyable. For millions of Americans living on fixed incomes, every additional dollar counts.

So when the Social Security Administration announced on Wednesday that beneficiaries will receive a 3.6% cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) in 2027, the largest increase since 2023, it sounded like welcome news. The average retirement benefit will rise by about $75 a month, to roughly $2,170, starting in January, and about 72 million Social Security recipients will see the increase.

In many ways, it is welcome news. But there's something a little uncomfortable about celebrating a bigger Social Security raise: The bigger the increase, the more it tells us about how much prices have been rising.

A Bigger Raise Isn't Always a Better Raise

That extra $75 isn't necessarily putting retirees ahead. It's meant to keep them from falling behind. Those are two very different things.

When most of us hear the word "raise," we think of something positive... a promotion, a reward for hard work, or simply more money left at the end of the month. If your employer gives you a 5% raise while your expenses stay about the same, your financial situation genuinely improves. You can save a little more, spend a little more, or just enjoy some extra breathing room.

Social Security raises don't work that way. The annual COLA isn't a reward or a bonus. It's an inflation adjustment, based on how much the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers (CPI-W) rose over the past year. In other words, the government measures how much consumer prices have increased and adjusts benefits to match.

That's an enormously important protection. Without it, a monthly benefit that felt sufficient at 67 could become woefully inadequate by 87. But it also means a larger COLA isn't a sign that retirees are doing better. More often, it's a sign that the cost of maintaining the same standard of living has gone up.

Consider the 8.7% COLA beneficiaries received in 2023, the largest in more than 40 years. On paper, it was an impressive raise. In reality, it reflected one of the most painful stretches of inflation in decades. Retirees weren't enjoying an 8.7% improvement in their lives; their benefits were catching up to prices that had already climbed sharply.

The same principle applies to the 3.6% increase coming in 2027.

Would You Rather Have a Bigger Check or Lower Prices?

Imagine two retirees who each receive $2,000 a month from Social Security.

The first gets a 2% COLA, bringing their benefit to $2,040, while the prices of the things they buy also rise about 2%. The second gets a 5% COLA, bringing their benefit to $2,100, but their prices rise 5%.

Which one is better off? Neither. Despite a much bigger dollar increase, the second retiree hasn't gained any purchasing power. Both are simply keeping pace with inflation.

Now change one detail: Suppose the first retiree's prices rose just 1% instead of 2%. Suddenly, that smaller 2% COLA is delivering a real improvement in what their check can buy.

The point isn't that retirees should root for tiny Social Security increases. It's that the size of the raise matters a lot less than what the money can actually buy. That tends to get lost in the excitement around the annual announcement.

Your Inflation Might Be Different

Even when the COLA accurately tracks the index it's based on, that index may not reflect your expenses.

The CPI-W measures price changes for households headed by working wage earners and clerical workers, not retirees. Older Americans tend to spend a larger share of their budgets on housing and health care, which don't always move in lockstep with overall prices. The Bureau of Labor Statistics actually publishes an experimental index designed to track spending by Americans 62 and older, known as the CPI-E, which weights those costs more heavily. But it isn't the one Social Security uses.

Where you live matters, too. Costs in a small Midwestern town don't rise the same way they do in Boston or San Francisco. And even two retirees in the same neighborhood can face very different expenses depending on their health, housing, and lifestyle.

So while benefits will rise 3.6% across the board, not every beneficiary's cost of living rose exactly 3.6%. Some will come out ahead. Others will find their bigger checks still don't stretch far enough.

Medicare matters here as well. Part B premiums are generally deducted directly from Social Security payments, so any increase comes out of the raise before it reaches your bank account. The Medicare trustees have projected that the standard Part B premium will rise about $6.60, to $209.50 a month, in 2027, and the official figure is expected later this fall. For the average retiree, that would still leave most of the $75 increase intact, but it's worth checking your own numbers.

What Retirees Should Pay Attention To

None of this means the 2027 COLA isn't worth celebrating. For someone struggling to pay the bills, an extra $75 a month can make a real difference, and automatic inflation adjustments are one of Social Security's most valuable features.

But rather than focusing on the size of the increase, retirees would be better served by asking a different question: Will my new benefit cover more of my expenses than my old one did?

You can start answering that now. Look at what you're spending on essentials like housing, food, utilities, transportation, and health care, and compare it with what you were paying a year ago. Social Security will send updated benefit notices in December, typically by mail and through your online account. When yours arrives, look at how much your actual payment will rise after Medicare premiums and any other deductions.

If your expenses have climbed faster than your benefit, your retirement budget may need some attention. If your benefit is keeping pace, or even gaining a little ground, that's worth recognizing, too.

And if you're still working and saving for retirement, there's a lesson here as well. Don't assume Social Security's annual adjustments will fully protect your future purchasing power. Inflation deserves a place in your retirement plan, even if part of your income will adjust automatically.

The Best Social Security Raise Might Be a Boring One

Every October, the COLA announcement generates headlines about how much more money retirees will receive, and naturally, a bigger number gets more attention.

But in an ideal world, retirees wouldn't need large annual increases just to stay in place. They'd have relatively stable prices, predictable expenses, and income that comfortably covered their needs. A modest COLA in a low-inflation economy can leave retirees better off than a much larger one in an economy where everyday necessities keep getting more expensive.

So yes, the 3.6% increase coming in 2027 is good news for the millions of Americans who depend on Social Security. It's just worth remembering what that increase represents.

A bigger check is nice. Being able to afford more with that check is what really matters.