Starbucks Corporation (SBUX Quick QuoteSBUX - Free Report) is trading at a forward 12-month price-to-earnings (P/E) multiple of 31.02, above the Zacks Retail – Restaurants industry average of 21.67. The roughly 43% premium raises the bar for Starbucks as it works to sustain its traffic recovery, restore margins and rebuild earnings.

SBUX’s P/E Ratio (Forward 12-Month) vs. Industry

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

The stock has gained 16% over the past year against the industry’s decline of 7.2%. Over the same period, Starbucks has also outperformed restaurant peers, including Dutch Bros Inc. (BROS Quick QuoteBROS - Free Report) and McDonald’s Corporation (MCD Quick QuoteMCD - Free Report) .

SBUX, MCD & BROS One-Year Price Performance

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Although improving operations have strengthened Starbucks’ investment case, the current multiple leaves limited room for slower growth or execution setbacks. The key question is whether the company can generate sufficient earnings improvement to justify buying the shares at this valuation.

Traffic and Store Execution Build SBUX’s Earnings Case

Starbucks’ third-quarter fiscal 2026 results provided encouraging evidence of improving demand. Global comparable sales increased 7.9% year over year, marking the fourth consecutive quarter of positive growth. U.S. comparable sales also rose 7.9%, driven by a 4.2% increase in transactions and a 3.6% improvement in average ticket.

The composition of the increase was favorable. Pricing contributed less than 1 percentage point to ticket growth, while delivery, beverage modifications and higher food attachment provided additional gains. Demand also improved across generations, income groups, access points and dayparts. This transaction-led growth provides a healthier foundation for earnings recovery than price-driven growth alone.

Execution improved alongside traffic. Starbucks achieved its target service times across every access point despite higher transaction volumes, while food availability approached 99%, approximately 10 percentage points better than a year earlier.

Coffeehouse uplifts offer another productivity lever. Starbucks surpassed 1,000 North American uplifts during the quarter and now plans to complete at least 1,500 by fiscal year-end. Early results indicate transaction improvement across formats, access points and dayparts. At an average investment of approximately $150,000 per location, the program carries a lower cost than earlier remodeling formats.

Margin Quality Is Critical to SBUX’s Premium

Consolidated operating margin expanded approximately 430 basis points year over year to 14.4% in the fiscal third quarter, while North America operating margin improved approximately 280 basis points. However, reciprocal tariff refunds boosted the reported results, making the headline expansion an imperfect measure of the underlying run rate.

The normalized trend was still constructive. Excluding the refunds, consolidated and North America operating margins improved year over year, with North America expanding by more than 100 basis points. Sales leverage, operational efficiencies and cost savings helped absorb investments in service and menu innovation.

Starbucks remains on track with its $2 billion gross cost-savings program through fiscal 2028. The company also raised its fiscal 2026 consolidated operating margin outlook to more than 11% and increased non-GAAP earnings guidance to $2.55-$2.65 per share. The Zacks Consensus Estimate calls for 21.6% earnings growth in fiscal 2026 and has moved higher over the past 60 days.

Balance-sheet improvement provides additional support. Starbucks used part of the China transaction proceeds to repay approximately $1.8 billion of debt, reducing leverage to 2.9 times. The lower debt burden enhances financial flexibility, but sustained underlying margin expansion remains more important to supporting the current earnings multiple.

BROS and MCD Raise the Bar for Beverage Growth

Dutch Bros continues to expand its beverage presence through shop development, product innovation and digital engagement. Second-quarter revenues increased 32%, while company-operated same-shop sales rose 8.3%, supported by 3.4% transaction growth. Myst Energy Refreshers increased the company’s energy mix and generated retention above recent limited-time-offer benchmarks.

Dutch Rewards represented more than 73% of transactions, while Order Ahead reached approximately 16% of the transaction mix. BROS also opened 48 shops during the quarter. Its combination of transaction growth, digital adoption and unit expansion strengthens its position in customizable cold beverages and afternoon occasions.

McDonald’s is pursuing additional beverage demand through a specialty lineup spanning cold coffee, crafted sodas, refreshers and energy drinks. Initial results across launch markets met or exceeded expectations, with more than half of beverage-related traffic occurring after lunch. Beverage orders generated an average check approximately 50% above the full-day average, supported by food attachment.

In Germany, where the complete lineup was available, MCD reported incremental contributions to comparable guest counts, sales and restaurant-level cash flow. McDonald’s can use its scale, value positioning and available restaurant capacity to build beverage demand without relying on a traditional coffeehouse format.

These developments make traffic durability more important to Starbucks’ valuation. BROS is expanding rapidly among beverage-focused consumers, while MCD is using its extensive footprint to create additional afternoon occasions. Starbucks must maintain product differentiation, loyalty engagement and service consistency to protect the growth assumptions embedded in its premium.

Execution Risks Could Pressure SBUX’s Valuation

Starbucks expects fiscal 2026 consolidated revenues to remain flat to slightly higher year over year, partly because the China joint-venture transition reduced reported revenues. Investors will need to distinguish that structural reporting impact from the underlying operating trend.

North American company-operated unit growth may also remain modest through fiscal 2027 as Starbucks prioritizes coffeehouse uplifts and reviews underperforming locations. Some stores could close as Starbucks addresses underperformance and past site selection or remodeling decisions.

Traffic comparisons are becoming more demanding as well. Starbucks expects fiscal fourth-quarter U.S. comparable sales growth of at least 6.5%, but consumer variability remains a consideration. A slowdown in transactions, weaker normalized margin improvement or downward earnings revisions could make the stock’s premium difficult to defend. Expanding competition from BROS and MCD adds to that risk, particularly across cold beverages, digital ordering and afternoon visits.

Buy the Brew or Skip SBUX Stock?

Starbucks’ operating recovery continues to strengthen, supported by positive transaction growth, better store execution and improving underlying margins. Cost savings, lower leverage and coffeehouse uplifts provide additional support for the company’s earnings outlook.

The Zacks Consensus Estimate calls for fiscal 2026 earnings growth of 21.6% and has increased 7.5% over the past 60 days. However, SBUX’s 31.02X forward P/E — roughly 43% above the industry average — already prices in meaningful progress. Reported margin growth partly benefited from tariff refunds; North American unit expansion is expected to remain modest, and BROS and MCD continue to compete for beverage demand. Given the premium valuation, any slowdown in traffic or underlying margin improvement could pressure the shares.

Against this backdrop, SBUX’s Zacks Rank #3 (Hold) supports a patient stance. Existing shareholders may retain the stock as operating momentum improves, while prospective investors may wait for a more attractive entry point. Starbucks’ improving fundamentals support holding the shares, but the current valuation argues against chasing them.

You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here.